Skip to main content

Paint Talk: The Products We Can’t Stand

Not all tools and supplies deliver on their promises in the painting world. Let’s examine the products that frustrate both professional painters and DIY enthusiasts and highlight the reasons behind their disappointment.

Introduction to Paint Talk

Paint Talk is a vibrant discussion platform for painting enthusiasts. It brings together professionals and amateurs to share insights about their favorite products and those they wish to avoid.

Community Engagement

Listeners can expect engaging conversations and honest reviews. The hosts encourage feedback, making it a collaborative space.

Product Reviews

Each episode features a mix of product recommendations and critiques. This approach helps everyone make informed choices when selecting painting tools.

The Pull Sander Debate

The pull sander has sparked a lively debate among painters. While some swear by its effectiveness, others find it frustrating to use.

Pros of the Pull Sander

  • Improved reach in tight spaces
  • Greater control during sanding
  • Less physical strain on hands

Cons of the Pull Sander

  • Inconsistent pressure application
  • Sandpaper may tear easily
  • Time-consuming to set up

The choice between a pull sander and other options, like power sanders, depends on personal preference and specific project needs. 

Self-Adhesive Patches: A Painful Experience

Self-adhesive patches seem like a quick fix for small wall holes, but they often lead to disappointing results. Many property managers rely on these patches, assuming they are effective, but the reality is quite different.

The Illusion of Simplicity

While self-adhesive patches appear easy to use, they rarely deliver the desired outcome. They typically consist of a metal backer, fiber tape, and a sticky surface.

Common Issues with Self-Adhesive Patches

  • Patches create unsightly mounds
  • Difficulty achieving a smooth finish
  • Sticky backing may fail over time
  • Patch size often grows during application

Instead of solving the problem, these patches can complicate repairs, leading to more work for both DIYers and professionals. In many cases, the patches do not adhere properly and can pop off weeks later.

Frustration for Professionals

Using self-adhesive patches can create extra work for professional painters. They often have to remove the failed patch and start from scratch.

Understanding California Patches

California patches offer a more effective solution for repairing small holes in drywall. They require a bit more effort but yield better results than self-adhesive options.

What is a California Patch?

A California patch involves cutting a piece of drywall to fit the hole and securing it with screws. This method provides a solid base for finishing and painting.

Advantages of California Patches

  • Creates a smoother finish
  • More durable than self-adhesive patches
  • Allows for proper adhesion and sealing
  • Suitable for various hole sizes

A California patch can be an easy DIY project for small holes. Many online tutorials guide you through the process.

Using 3M Patch Kits

If you’re dealing with larger holes, 3M offers patch kits that are effective and user-friendly. These kits can handle larger repairs and provide a better finish than self-adhesive patches.

Steps for a Successful California Patch

  1. Cut a piece of drywall to fit the hole.
  2. Secure a wooden backing inside the wall.
  3. Screw the drywall piece into the backing.
  4. Apply joint compound for a smooth finish.

This method ensures a professional-looking repair that stands the test of time. For best results, follow a few tutorials to get the technique down.

The 5-in-1 Tool vs. Caulking Tools

The 5-in-1 tool is a staple for many painters, offering multiple functions in one handy device. However, some caulking tools claim to provide similar benefits, leading to confusion among users.

Why the 5-in-1 Tool Wins

Many professionals rely on the 5-in-1 tool because of its versatility and effectiveness. It can handle various tasks, which makes it a favorite among painters.

  • Scraping paint and caulk
  • Opening paint cans
  • Spreading putty
  • Removing old caulk
  • Achieving a smooth finish

The Limitations of Caulking Tools

While caulking tools are marketed as innovative, they often fall short of expectations. Many users find these tools unnecessary and less effective than traditional methods.

  • Limited flexibility
  • Not suitable for all surfaces
  • Often replaced by fingers
  • Commonly underperform

Experienced painters typically prefer the 5-in-1 tool for its reliability and proven performance. The need for a specialized caulking tool is often questioned.

The Frustration of Stress Crack Tape

Stress crack tape is marketed as an easy solution for repairing cracks in walls. However, many users quickly realize that it often leads to more problems than it solves.

Understanding Stress Crack Tape

This product is essentially a pre-textured sticker designed to cover cracks in drywall. Despite its claims, many find it ineffective and unsightly.

  • Available in textured and smooth finishes
  • Claims to be paintable
  • Supposed to blend seamlessly

Common Issues with Stress Crack Tape

Users frequently report several problems when using stress crack tape. These issues can lead to frustration and a lack of confidence in the product.

  • Bubbles under the surface
  • Visible seams after painting
  • Not adhering properly
  • Looks worse than regular tape

Many believe that stress crack tape is just a poor substitute for traditional repair methods. The expectation of a seamless finish often leads to disappointment.

The Illusion of Step Saver Products

Step saver products often promise to make repairs easier, but they can be misleading. Many users find that these products do not perform as expected, leading to more work in the long run.

Understanding the Reality

Many of these products are marketed as time-savers, but they often create additional challenges. For instance, stress crack tape is simply a sticker that covers cracks, but it doesn’t provide a lasting solution.

Common Misconceptions

  • Easy application leads to quick fixes
  • Assumed durability and effectiveness
  • Expectation of seamless results

In reality, these products can complicate repairs, making it essential to rely on traditional methods for lasting results.

Common Mistakes with Crack Repair

Crack repair can be tricky, and many homeowners make common mistakes that hinder their efforts. Understanding these pitfalls can lead to better results.

Over-Reliance on Quick Fixes

Using products like stress crack tape without proper preparation often leads to disappointment. Many find that these solutions are temporary at best.

Neglecting Surface Preparation

  • Not cleaning the area before application
  • Ignoring the need for priming
  • Failing to choose the right filler

Proper preparation is key to achieving a smooth, long-lasting repair. Taking the time to do it right can save effort later.

Final Thoughts on Painting Products

Choosing the right painting products can greatly impact your project. While some products may promise ease, others can lead to frustration.

Key Takeaways

It’s essential to research and test products before committing. Always consider professional recommendations for the best results.

Frequently Asked Questions

Here are some common questions about painting products.

What Should I Consider When Choosing Painting Products?

When selecting painting products, consider the following factors to ensure you achieve the best results:

  • Durability: Choose products known for their long-lasting finish and resistance to wear and tear, especially for high-traffic areas.
  • Ease of Use: Opt for paints that offer easy application, good coverage, and minimal splattering to make the painting process smoother.
  • Professional Reviews: Research professional reviews and ratings to gauge the performance and reliability of different products.
  • Environmental Impact: Consider eco-friendly options that have low VOC (volatile organic compounds) to reduce harmful emissions and improve indoor air quality.
  • Finish Options: Select the appropriate finish (matte, satin, semi-gloss, or gloss) based on the desired look and functional needs of the space.

Are There Products I Should Avoid?

Yes, avoid products that have consistently poor reviews or those that are known to complicate repairs. Also, steer clear of:

  • Low-Quality Paints: These may require multiple coats and still fail to provide good coverage or durability.
  • High VOC Paints: These can emit harmful fumes, affecting indoor air quality and health.
  • Products with Inconsistent Performance: Paints that don’t perform well in various conditions can lead to a less-than-desirable finish.

How Do I Determine the Right Amount of Paint to Buy?

To avoid running out of paint mid-project or having too much leftover, calculate the area to be painted and consider the paint’s coverage rate. Most paint cans indicate the coverage area per gallon. It’s also wise to buy a little extra to account for touch-ups and future repairs.

What Tools and Supplies Will I Need for a Successful Paint Job?

Having the right tools and supplies is essential for a smooth painting process. Key items include:

  • High-Quality Brushes and Rollers: For even application and to avoid streaks and marks.
  • Painter’s Tape: To protect edges and ensure clean lines.
  • Drop Cloths: To protect floors and furniture from drips and spills.
  • Sandpaper and Primer: For surface preparation, ensuring better paint adhesion.
  • Paint Trays and Stir Sticks: For mixing and easy access to paint during the job.

With these tips in mind, you can choose the best paint products for your next project! 


Let’s be honest—there’s a lot of junk on the shelves these days. Flashy labels, big promises, and trendy names might grab attention, but when it comes down to performance, some painting products just don’t deliver. From paints that streak and fade within weeks to tools that fall apart mid-job, we’ve seen it all—and we’re not afraid to call it out.

At That 1 Painter, we’ve tested just about every brush, roller, tape, and paint brand out there. And while we love discovering a product that makes our work smoother and your finish better, we’ve also run into more than a few total flops. Cheap brushes that shed bristles like a golden retriever, painter’s tape that bleeds like it’s never heard of a straight line, and “premium” paints that take five coats to cover white walls? Hard pass.

Here’s the thing: bad products don’t just make our jobs harder—they ruin the final result. We’re talking streaks, uneven coverage, premature peeling, and finishes that look dull before the paint’s even dry. And that’s just not acceptable when you’re paying for professional-quality work.

We believe in using the right tools, the right paint, and the right prep—every time. That means we stay away from the cheap gimmicks and stick with products that are tried, tested, and proven to perform.

Want to see what we actually do recommend? Check out our YouTube channel for no-BS product reviews, side-by-side comparisons, and behind-the-scenes footage from real job sites.

Tired of wasting time and money on products that don’t live up to the hype? Let That 1 Painter show you what a real professional-grade finish looks like. Contact us today for a free estimate and let’s do it right the first time.

READY TO GET STARTED?

Contact us for a free onsite estimate within 24 hours.

BOOK NOW