What Is the Best Paint Sheen for Interior Walls?
Choosing between flat, eggshell, satin, and semi-gloss depends on the room's traffic, lighting, and function. Professional painters break down when to use each sheen for the best results.


We paint across Atlantic Beach, Fleming Island, and Green Cove Springs with consistent prep, premium products, and a 3-year transferable warranty. Our crew on the First Coast specializes in interior repaints, exterior siding refresh, cabinet refinishing, deck staining, drywall repair, and limewash, all engineered to hold up against Florida's subtropical coastal climate.

Transform your living spaces with flawless color and finish.

Curb appeal that lasts. Expert coatings for every climate.

Professional-grade finishes that elevate your business space.

Refresh your kitchen with a smooth, factory-quality finish.

Authentic European lime-based finishes for timeless texture and depth.

Breathe new life into brick with lasting, beautiful color.

Transform your living spaces with flawless color and finish.

Curb appeal that lasts. Expert coatings for every climate.

Professional-grade finishes that elevate your business space.

Refresh your kitchen with a smooth, factory-quality finish.

Authentic European lime-based finishes for timeless texture and depth.

Breathe new life into brick with lasting, beautiful color.
Trusted Paint Partners

Owned by Gina & Tony Schlicksup, That 1 Painter First Coast brings local accountability and a 3-year warranty to every Atlantic Beach, Fleming Island, and Green Cove Springs project. Our services cover interior painting, exterior painting, cabinet refinishing, and specialty finishes.
Your painting project means as much to us as it does to you. We're fully insured, and our promise is simple: we'll be your best house guests, treating your place with the utmost care and leaving it even more pristine than when we arrived.
That 1 Painter First Coast is a locally owned and operated painting company led by GINA & TONY SCHLICKSUP, serving First Coast and surrounding communities with insured crews and a 3-year transferable warranty.

That 1 Painter First Coast serves Jacksonville, the Beaches, St. Johns, St. Augustine, and the surrounding Clay and Duval communities.
Jacksonville anchors our First Coast market, and crews work across Downtown, Riverside, San Marco, Southside, Arlington, and the Westside. Bungalows in Avondale, brick and stucco homes off Beach Boulevard, and mid-century blocks near the river all show up in a normal week of estimates.
The St. Johns River corridor, humid summers, and salt-air drift shape how exteriors are prepped: pressure wash, mildew treatment, UV-rated primer, and moisture-tolerant top coats. Interior scopes lean toward scuff-resistant eggshells, and cabinet refinishing is a common ask for kitchens built in the 1990s and 2000s.
Jax Beach homes take a beating from salt spray, sand, and constant sun, so exterior work is a systems job. We wash the envelope, spot-prime chalking stucco and weathered fiber cement, replace failed caulk lines at trim and windows, and finish with 100% acrylic or elastomeric built for beachside exposure.
Interiors here often mean lightening rooms after decades of yellowed walls and popcorn ceilings, or refreshing rentals between tenants. Older canal-street homes with solid-wood kitchens are strong candidates for cabinet refinishing rather than replacement, especially when the boxes are worth saving with a factory-grade enamel.
Atlantic Beach mixes classic beach cottages, mid-century ranches, and newer coastal builds, and each asks for a different approach. Exterior projects usually start with a serious wash for salt and mildew, followed by wood repair on trim, fascia, and soffits, then a coastal-grade system that stands up to ocean air.
Interiors tend toward light coastal palettes: whites, soft grays, and pale blues that read well in strong Florida daylight. Cabinet refinishing is common in tired oak and maple kitchens, brought back in durable white or greige enamels without replacing the boxes.
Neptune Beach is small, walkable, and full of homes that have been added onto and remodeled over decades, which makes prep the most important step. Crews strip failing layers, sand and feather edges, prime bare wood, and rebuild caulk lines before finish coats go on.
Interior refreshes often pair with trim upgrades and door refinishing, and there is steady demand for cabinet work from homeowners who want a modern kitchen without a full remodel. Doors and drawer fronts get sprayed, back-brushed where it matters, and cured in place for a factory-quality result.
Ponte Vedra Beach projects tend to be larger, higher-spec, and more design-driven, so we staff them with a dedicated lead, detailed color drawdowns, and daily walk-throughs. Exteriors usually involve stucco patching, wood trim replacement on fascia and soffits, and premium 100% acrylic systems.
Interior work here ranges from whole-home refreshes and level-5 drywall finishes in new construction to color consultations for coastal contemporary and transitional homes. Cabinet refinishing is often part of a larger kitchen upgrade, sprayed in a controlled environment with conversion varnishes or waterborne alkyd enamels for a hard, durable result.
Nocatee is newer construction, so most homes are still on their original builder-grade coatings. The first upgrade here is usually interior, moving great rooms, primary suites, and kids' rooms into higher-grade, scrubbable finishes that hold up to family life.
Exterior work comes into play around the 7 to 10 year mark, when Florida sun starts breaking down the original builder finish on stucco and trim. Cabinet refinishing is also common when families move in and want to personalize a builder kitchen without a full remodel.
St. Johns is one of our busiest submarkets on the First Coast, with a mix of newer subdivisions and established neighborhoods along the river. Typical scopes here run from interior refreshes for new-owner move-ins to full exteriors on stucco and Hardie homes, plus cabinet refinishing for kitchens ready for a durable update.
HOA-approved color palettes, matching existing trim finishes, and coordinating with landscapers and roofers on exterior jobs are all part of a normal St. Johns project. Schedules run around school calendars and in phases so families can stay in the home while work is in progress.
Fruit Cove homes along the St. Johns River deal with dense tree canopies, high humidity, and long stretches of shaded siding, which means mildew, algae, and premature coating failure on the exterior. Crews soft-wash the entire envelope, treat problem areas, and specify mildew-resistant top coats.
Interior work is often tied to remodels, additions, or refreshing homes that have been in the family for years. Cabinet refinishing is a common ask, especially in the larger kitchens where full replacement runs into the tens of thousands and the existing layout is worth preserving.
St. Augustine's mix of historic downtown homes, coastal cottages, and newer developments west of I-95 makes every project a little different. Historic-district exteriors demand careful color matching, wood repair, and coating systems compatible with older substrates, so those jobs are planned around weather windows and HARB guidelines when applicable.
Interior scopes here cover everything from vacation-rental turnovers to owner-occupied whole-home refreshes. Cabinet refinishing for St. Augustine kitchens often pairs with restoring built-ins and trim, bringing the whole first floor into one cohesive palette.
World Golf Village and the surrounding communities off International Golf Parkway have a large share of stucco homes, tile roofs, and mature landscaping, all of which factor into an exterior plan. Crews wash, patch, prime, and recoat stucco with elastomeric or acrylic systems chosen for the specific substrate condition.
Interior work often means opening up dated color palettes with lighter neutrals. Cabinet refinishing is a fast way to modernize the large builder kitchens common in these neighborhoods without gutting the space.
Green Cove Springs mixes historic riverfront homes, older bungalows, and newer construction on the outskirts, and each substrate calls for a different exterior approach. Crews handle wood siding, Hardie board, stucco, and brick, matching primer and finish systems to what is actually on the wall.
Interior scopes often run alongside light renovation, trim upgrades, and door refinishing. Cabinet work is a strong option here for the many mid-century and 1990s-era kitchens where the boxes and layout are solid but the finish is worn.
Orange Park's mature neighborhoods off US-17 include a lot of homes 20 to 40 years old, which is the sweet spot for interior refreshes, exterior work, and cabinet refinishing. Exteriors here are prep-heavy: scraping chalked coatings, replacing rotted trim, and installing a fresh 100% acrylic system that resets the maintenance clock.
Interior work in Orange Park is often a top-to-bottom refresh after buying an older home, covering walls, ceilings, trim, and doors. Cabinet refinishing gives homeowners a modern look while keeping the original solid-wood construction intact.
Middleburg's larger lots, wooded settings, and mix of manufactured, block, and stick-built homes mean crews plan each exterior around substrate, sun exposure, and tree cover. Mildew treatment, primer selection, and finish sheen all get tuned to the specific home.
Interior scopes range from single accent walls to whole-house work during a move-in, and there is a healthy amount of cabinet refinishing on kitchens that are structurally solid but finished in dated stains or worn white.
A look at the craftsmanship we bring to homes and businesses across the First Coast. From full-home interior repaints and kitchen cabinet refinishing to exterior siding, stucco, and trim work, every painting project in the First Coast is prepped, primed, and finished by insured local painters. Browse recent residential and commercial painting projects to see the color matching, surface prep, and clean lines homeowners across the First Coast trust us to deliver.

Every year, our team on the First Coast teams up with franchise owners across the country to gift complete paint transformations to deserving families, small businesses, and non-profits. It's our way of giving back to the community that's given us so much, one home, one story, one fresh coat at a time.
Learn More About Paint It Forward
What painting really costs on the First Coast in 2026: this guide is built from completed jobs across Atlantic Beach, Fleming Island, and Green Cove Springs, priced for Florida's subtropical coastal climate and the prep depth it demands.
* All prices include materials, labor, and prep. Based on 2026 the First Coast averages.

Your peace of mind, at the top of mind with our three-year transferable warranty. Covers the painting job, even if you sell the house.
Download WarrantyEverything First Coast homeowners should know before hiring a painter, services, seasonal timing, colors, HOA rules, and how to get the most value from your project. Written by the That 1 Painter First Coast team.
Book an Appointment
Three simple steps from request to wow-worthy finish.
Book your appointment
Pick a service, date & time that works for you.
Walk the project & get your quote
A local pro confirms scope and sends a clear written estimate.
We paint, you say wow
Our crew shows up on time and leaves the space spotless.
Pick a service, date & time, we'll handle the rest.
Honest product reviews, pro painting techniques, and helpful articles from professional painters who do this every day.
Choosing between flat, eggshell, satin, and semi-gloss depends on the room's traffic, lighting, and function. Professional painters break down when to use each sheen for the best results.
Both are popular mid-tier Sherwin-Williams paints, but they perform differently on walls, trim, and cabinets. See how professional painters compare coverage, feel, and durability.
Behr Premium Plus is one of the most affordable paints at Home Depot. Professional painters test its coverage, durability, and finish quality to see if it's worth the price.
Behr Urethane Alkyd is a hybrid paint that combines oil-based durability with water-based cleanup. See how it performs on trim, cabinets, and doors in a real-world test.
Behr Dynasty claims to be their most durable, stain-repellent paint. Professional painters put it to the test on walls and high-traffic areas to see if the claims hold up.
The Gallery Series is Sherwin-Williams' newest premium line. Professional painters review its unique properties and explain why it may not be the best choice for beginners.
Clear answers about pricing, timelines, services, warranty coverage, and working with That 1 Painter.