What Is the Best Paint Sheen for Interior Walls?
Choosing between flat, eggshell, satin, and semi-gloss depends on the room's traffic, lighting, and function. Professional painters break down when to use each sheen for the best results.


Our Cape Cod, MA crews paint everything: walls, ceilings, trim, doors, cabinets, exteriors, decks, and commercial interiors. We work across Barnstable, Bourne, and Brewster with the durability standards required by a cold-winter Northeastern climate.

Transform your living spaces with flawless color and finish.

Curb appeal that lasts. Expert coatings for every climate.

Professional-grade finishes that elevate your business space.

Refresh your kitchen with a smooth, factory-quality finish.

Authentic European lime-based finishes for timeless texture and depth.

Breathe new life into brick with lasting, beautiful color.

Transform your living spaces with flawless color and finish.

Curb appeal that lasts. Expert coatings for every climate.

Professional-grade finishes that elevate your business space.

Refresh your kitchen with a smooth, factory-quality finish.

Authentic European lime-based finishes for timeless texture and depth.

Breathe new life into brick with lasting, beautiful color.
Trusted Paint Partners

My name is Tony Arsenault. I’m a husband and proud father of four amazing adult children. Professionally, I spent more than 30 years as a Corporate Sales Executive before transitioning into the next chapter of my journey as an entrepreneur and business investor. After decades in the corporate world, I realized it was time to channel my experience, leadership, and unwavering drive into building something with deeper purpose—a local company rooted in service, community, and people-first values. My vision is to create a culture where everyone matters: our employees, our painters, our referral partners, and of course, our clients. While we bring the expertise and professionalism of a big business, we operate with the heart, care, and personal touch of a small business. At the end of the day, my goal is simple: to create meaningful impact, deliver exceptional results, and change people’s lives for the better.
Your painting project means as much to us as it does to you. We're licensed and insured, and our promise is simple: we'll be your best house guests, treating your place with the utmost care and leaving it even more pristine than when we arrived.

Based in Hyannis, That 1 Painter Cape Cod paints across the Cape and the islands, Falmouth, Barnstable, and out to Nantucket, 81 coastal communities served by one local crew, with free estimates.
100 Independence Dr., Ste. 7-967
Hyannis, MA 02601
A look at the craftsmanship we bring to homes and businesses across Cape Cod. From full-home interior repaints and kitchen cabinet refinishing to exterior siding, stucco, and trim work, every painting project in Cape Cod is prepped, primed, and finished by licensed, insured local painters. Browse recent residential and commercial painting projects to see the color matching, surface prep, and clean lines homeowners across Cape Cod trust us to deliver.

Every year, our Cape Cod team teams up with franchise owners across the country to gift complete paint transformations to deserving families, small businesses, and non-profits. It's our way of giving back to the community that's given us so much, one home, one story, one fresh coat at a time.
Learn More About Paint It Forward
Honest pricing for Cape Cod homeowners, built from current 2026 job data across Barnstable, Bourne, and Brewster. Every line below reflects real Massachusetts conditions: harsh winter freeze-thaw, ice dams, and salt-laden coastal air, scaffolding access, and product specs that actually last.
* All prices include materials, labor, and prep. Based on 2026 Cape Cod averages.

Your peace of mind, at the top of mind with our three-year transferable warranty. Covers the painting job, even if you sell the house.
Download WarrantyEverything Cape Cod homeowners should know before hiring a painter, services, seasonal timing, colors, HOA rules, and how to get the most value from your project. Written by the That 1 Painter Cape Cod team.
Book an Appointment
Three simple steps from request to wow-worthy finish.
Book your appointment
Pick a service, date & time that works for you.
Walk the project & get your quote
A local pro confirms scope and sends a clear written estimate.
We paint, you say wow
Our crew shows up on time and leaves the space spotless.
Pick a service, date & time, we'll handle the rest.
Honest product reviews, pro painting techniques, and helpful articles from professional painters who do this every day.
Choosing between flat, eggshell, satin, and semi-gloss depends on the room's traffic, lighting, and function. Professional painters break down when to use each sheen for the best results.
Both are popular mid-tier Sherwin-Williams paints, but they perform differently on walls, trim, and cabinets. See how professional painters compare coverage, feel, and durability.
Behr Premium Plus is one of the most affordable paints at Home Depot. Professional painters test its coverage, durability, and finish quality to see if it's worth the price.
Behr Urethane Alkyd is a hybrid paint that combines oil-based durability with water-based cleanup. See how it performs on trim, cabinets, and doors in a real-world test.
Behr Dynasty claims to be their most durable, stain-repellent paint. Professional painters put it to the test on walls and high-traffic areas to see if the claims hold up.
The Gallery Series is Sherwin-Williams' newest premium line. Professional painters review its unique properties and explain why it may not be the best choice for beginners.
Clear answers about pricing, timelines, services, warranty coverage, and working with That 1 Painter.
Interior painting is the fastest way to change how a home on Cape Cod feels without touching the floor plan, and it is the busiest scope our crews run across the Cape and Islands from the Sagamore Bridge out to the Outer Cape and across the water to Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard. Our interior painting scope covers walls, ceilings, trim, doors, and closets, and every interior painting job in Cape Cod starts with a real prep pass so the interior painting film has a clean, sound surface to bond to. Homeowners searching for painters in Cape Cod for an interior painting refresh usually want two upgrades at once: an updated color palette and a durable, scrubbable interior painting finish that survives long coastal New England winters spent indoors with the heat running dry and long humid summers cycling salt-laden air through open windows.
As a painting company in Cape Cod that runs interior painting on Hyannis and Barnstable year-round Capes and shingle-style homes, Falmouth and Mashpee waterfront cottages, Sandwich and Bourne canal-side Colonials, Chatham and Orleans classic Cape and saltbox stock, Provincetown, Truro, and Wellfleet Outer Cape cottages and dune-shack seasonal builds, Brewster and Eastham mid-Cape ranches, Osterville and Cotuit estate homes, Nantucket historic in-town Federals and 'Sconset cottages, Martha's Vineyard shingle-style estates, and South Shore Plymouth, Duxbury, Marshfield, Scituate, Cohasset, and Hingham Colonials, we treat interior painting material selection as a real decision, not a checkbox. Which interior painting sheen hides plaster imperfection under strong south-facing summer light in a Chatham great room, which interior painting product holds up in a Falmouth mudroom that catches wet sandy boots eight months a year, and which interior painting primer we need to lock down previously oil-based trim in a 1920s Osterville cottage are all questions we answer before the crew shows up. That level of interior painting discipline is why homeowners hire house painters in Cape Cod like us instead of a general handyman.
If you're comparing interior painting bids from painters in Cape Cod, ask each of them about interior painting warranty terms, interior painting prep sequence, and how the interior painting crew protects floors and furniture day to day. Every serious interior painting outfit on the Cape and Islands should have plain answers to all three. See our interior painting page for the full interior painting scope and current pricing across the Cape, the South Shore, and the Islands.
Exterior painting in Cape Cod has to hold up to punishing salt air that pulls chalking and mildew onto every elevation from Provincetown to Plymouth, freeze-thaw cycles that pop caulk lines on the north sides of Falmouth, Chatham, and Nantucket homes, Nor'easter wind and driving rain from October through April, ice storms and heavy snow loading through January and February, and long humid August stretches where nothing cures fast, so exterior painting product choice is the whole conversation, not a footnote. A painting company in Cape Cod that takes exterior painting seriously specifies a 100% acrylic exterior painting product with a mildew inhibitor built into the exterior painting film and flexibility rated for coastal New England freeze-thaw movement, so shaded north elevations under mature Barnstable and Brewster oaks and full-sun elevations on Truro and Wellfleet dune-facing builds stay clean between exterior painting cycles.
Our exterior painting scope typically includes a full pressure wash to lift salt film, a mildew-and-chalking assessment, spot scraping of any failing exterior painting layers, cedar-shingle, painted-clapboard, shake, and painted-brick sound-substrate checks, feathered sanding, spot primer on bare substrate, full caulk of siding seams and window returns, and two coats of exterior painting-grade paint. That exterior painting sequence is the same whether we are painting a classic Chatham saltbox, a Falmouth shingle-style cottage, an Osterville waterfront estate, a South Shore Duxbury Colonial, a Nantucket in-town Federal, or a Martha's Vineyard shingle-style home. Painters in Cape Cod who skip any of those exterior painting steps are quoting a two-year paint job in a ten-year paint job wrapper.
If you're evaluating house painters in Cape Cod for exterior painting, look closely at how the exterior painting bid describes prep, not just the exterior painting product line. A clean exterior painting film applied over poor prep will peel inside a single Nor'easter cycle. Our exterior painting service documents the exterior painting prep sequence in detail, and every exterior painting job we run carries a 3-year transferable warranty.
Cabinet painting is the single biggest visual change a homeowner on Cape Cod can buy without a full kitchen remodel, and cabinet painting demand across Hyannis, Falmouth, Chatham, and Nantucket reflects that. Our cabinet painting scope typically covers cabinet boxes on-site plus cabinet doors and drawer fronts sprayed off-site in a controlled environment, so the cabinet painting finish flows out flat and cures without airborne dust or humid August salt air. Cabinet painting projects like this are why homeowners call a painting company in Cape Cod instead of a general remodeler.
Cabinet painting product selection matters as much as cabinet painting prep. A real cabinet painting job uses a bonding primer, a cabinet-grade urethane-modified acrylic paint, and controlled drying conditions so the cabinet painting film cures hard enough to resist door-edge chipping under daily use in a busy Osterville or Chatham kitchen. As a painting company in Cape Cod that runs cabinet painting jobs almost every week; heavier in the off-season around rental turnovers; we schedule cabinet painting projects so the kitchen is out of service only for the days doors and drawers are physically off.
House painters on the Cape and Islands quoting cabinet painting should walk you through cabinet painting cure times, cabinet painting warranty coverage, and cabinet painting color options with real drawdowns on your actual cabinet material. Cabinet painting is not a wall paint job with cabinets in the way, and any painting company in Cape Cod that treats it that way is one to avoid for cabinet painting scopes. See our cabinet painting page for cabinet painting scope details and lead times.
There are a lot of painters in Cape Cod to choose from, so the practical question is how to sort serious painters in Cape Cod from casual ones. Any painting outfit you bid should carry general liability insurance, provide a written scope, and back the work with a real written warranty. They should also point at recent portfolio work in your specific corner of the market; Hyannis and Barnstable year-round Capes, Falmouth and Mashpee waterfront cottages, Chatham and Orleans saltbox and classic Cape stock, Outer Cape Wellfleet and Truro dune cottages, Nantucket historic in-town Federals, Martha's Vineyard shingle-style estates, or South Shore Duxbury and Cohasset Colonials; not stock photos pulled from a supplier catalog.
As house painters in Cape Cod ourselves, we tell homeowners to ask three questions of anyone bidding: what is the exact prep sequence, what specific paint product is going on the walls, and who from the company is on site day to day. Painters on the Cape and Islands who dodge those questions are hoping you will not notice the answer later. A painting company in Cape Cod that answers plainly is one worth a second meeting.
That 1 Painter Cape Cod, run by Tony Arsenault out of Hyannis 02601, is one of many painters in Cape Cod, and we compete on scope clarity, prep quality, and a 3-year transferable warranty that follows the paint, not the owner. If you are collecting bids from painters in Cape Cod, the South Shore, and the Islands, we would be glad to be one of the bids you compare against.
A real painting company in Cape Cod is more than a paint crew: it runs estimates, project management, materials logistics, color consultations, and warranty follow-up so the crew painting your house can focus on painting. That coordination is the difference between a painting company in Cape Cod and a solo painter working out of a truck bed. It is also the difference between a paint job that lands on the promised week and a paint job that drifts a month past schedule when a September Nor'easter or a February ice storm sits over the Cape.
As a painting company in Cape Cod, our day starts with materials staging for that day's painting scope, drives out to active painting jobs from Hyannis and Barnstable across to Falmouth, Chatham, Orleans, Brewster, Sandwich, Mashpee, Yarmouth, and out to Provincetown, plus ferry-scheduled runs to Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard and South Shore work in Plymouth, Duxbury, Marshfield, Scituate, Cohasset, and Hingham, and ends with paint punch-list walks with homeowners. A painting company in Cape Cod running this way keeps painting projects on schedule and keeps paint quality consistent from the first painting day to the last painting day of a job, even when the schedule wraps ferry crossings and bridge traffic. Homeowners feel that consistency in a lot of small ways; cleaner cut lines, tighter caulk joints, fewer callback punch items.
When you hire a painting company in Cape Cod, you are hiring the coordination layer as much as the painting itself. A painting company on the Cape and Islands that quotes a painting scope should tell you what week your painting starts, what week it ends, and who owns the project through completion. If a painting company in Cape Cod cannot articulate what is included in the price on the bid, that is a signal to keep shopping.
Older homes across the Cape and Islands market; 1700s-1800s Sandwich, Barnstable, and Chatham Capes and saltboxes, Nantucket in-town Federals and 'Sconset cottages, Martha's Vineyard captain's houses in Edgartown and Vineyard Haven, Osterville and Cotuit turn-of-the-century estate homes, and South Shore Plymouth and Duxbury Colonials; need house painters in Cape Cod who understand plaster, painted-wood clapboard, cedar shingle, and the way early paint layers move under fresh coats through a coastal New England Nor'easter winter. House painters on the Cape who came up on new-construction repaints alone often underestimate how much prep an older Cape Cod home actually needs before the first drop of paint goes on the wall.
House painters in Cape Cod running an older home job spend the first day on paint testing, cedar-shingle scrape-and-sand prep, glazing repair on original six-over-six divided-light windows, and containment for scrape-and-paint work outside. Skipping those steps produces a paint job that fails inside a single freeze-thaw cycle. As house painters in Cape Cod with real time on Chatham, Sandwich, Nantucket, and Edgartown blocks, we treat prep as the paint job; the coats you see are the last five percent of the actual work.
If you own an older home and are talking to house painters in Cape Cod, ask each bidder to walk your house and describe what they would do differently versus a 1990s Mashpee build or a 2020s Plymouth new construction. The house painters on the Cape and Islands with a real answer are the ones to shortlist. Beyond older homes, our crews also cover new-build repaints, HOA-driven exterior refreshes across South Shore townhome runs, seasonal-rental turnovers in Falmouth and Wellfleet coordinated around booking calendars, and estate-scale scopes in Osterville and on the Islands coordinated with ferry schedules and gated-community access, so the crew on your project has seen your situation before.
Color is where a lot of painting projects across the Cape and Islands market stall, so the painters you hire should have a real color process. Ours starts with existing light in the room, existing floor and trim tones, and the direction the room faces, then we put real paint drawdowns on your actual walls before the crew mobilizes. A painting company in Cape Cod that hands you a fan deck and walks away will paint whatever you point at, which is not the same as helping you land the right color for the space; an especially real risk in coastal New England where bright summer beach light and long overcast winter stretches change how a color reads through half the year.
Finish selection is the other half of the conversation. Flat or matte on ceilings, eggshell or matte on walls, satin or semi-gloss on trim, and a cabinet-grade product on cabinets; that mix reads intentional in a finished home across the Cape. Painters in Cape Cod who put one paint sheen everywhere are cutting corners on materials logistics, not doing you a favor. House painters on the Cape and Islands that pair color and finish thoughtfully deliver a paint job that reads like a designer walked the space with them.
Booking a painting company in Cape Cod should be simple: a walk-through, a written scope, a written price, a start date, and a warranty. Exterior painting demand peaks in the May-through-October window across coastal New England before Nor'easter season shuts the exterior season down, so any painting company in Cape Cod worth hiring is often booked several weeks out during peak exterior painting season; Islands work especially, because ferry logistics limit how many crews can be over at once. Interior painting flexes year-round and is easiest to schedule in the off-season around rental turns, and cabinet painting we can usually schedule with less lead time. Request an estimate above and we will be out with a written scope you can compare against every other bid on your desk.