Skip to main content

Choosing the Right Shade of White: Transform Your Space with Confidence in 2025

That 1 Painter is the fastest-growing painting company in the world. Painting your space can be complicated, but with our expertise, we make the process easy and stress-free for homeowners. With franchises across the nation, we have helped tens of thousands of homeowners make the best choices for their homes without sacrificing quality, and we are here to show you how.

Choosing the Right Shade of White: Transform Your Space with Confidence in 2025

White is never just white.

It’s creamy, crisp, soft, stark, warm, cool—it’s everything except one-size-fits-all. In fact, according to Sherwin-Williams, white is the most requested interior paint color in America, yet it’s also the most misunderstood.

With hundreds of options on the market, how do you choose the right one?

You’ve probably stood in a paint store, overwhelmed by names like Chantilly Lace, White Dove, or Alabaster. At first glance, they all look the same—but line them up, and you’ll see big differences. That’s because lighting, undertones, and even paint finish all affect how white appears on your walls.

Here at That 1 Painter Williamsburg, we see this all the time. Homeowners think they want “white,” but quickly realize there’s a whole world of white to consider. We’ve helped hundreds of families make the right call—and now we’re here to help you, too.

Let’s explore what really goes into choosing the perfect white for your space.

Know Your Undertones: The Secret Ingredient Behind Every White

Undertones are what give each white paint its unique character. They’re the hidden colors beneath the surface—and they can change everything.

  • Warm undertones (yellow, red, pink): These whites feel cozy and soft. Perfect for living rooms and bedrooms.
  • Cool undertones (blue, gray, green): These give a cleaner, more modern look. Great for bathrooms or bright kitchens.
  • Neutral whites: These don’t lean warm or cool. They work well on ceilings, trim, or in minimalist spaces.

👉 Quick trick: Hold a white paint swatch next to a sheet of plain printer paper. That paper is pure white, so any undertones in the swatch will jump out.

A white that looks bright in the store might look yellow next to your hardwood floors—or turn blue in your sunroom. That’s why undertones matter so much.

Let Lighting Be Your Guide: Why Whites Shift in Every Room

Light plays a huge role in how we see color—especially white.

A warm white might look perfect in the morning, then turn beige by sunset. That’s because natural and artificial light affect the way colors appear. Here’s how different lighting can change your white paint:

  • North-facing rooms have cool, bluish light. Go with warm whites to add balance.
  • South-facing rooms get strong natural light all day. Most whites look bright and clean here.
  • East-facing rooms are cooler in the morning, warmer later in the day. Choose flexible whites that don’t shift too much.
  • West-facing rooms can feel very warm at sunset. Cool whites can help tone that down.

💡 Pro tip: Always test your paint choices in different corners of the room—especially near windows and lamps. See how the color looks at different times of day.

At That 1 Painter Williamsburg, we never paint without testing first. It’s the best way to avoid surprises and make sure the color feels right.

Match the Room Mood: Picking the Right White for Each Space

Your white paint should match the feeling you want in each room. Let’s break it down:

🛋 Living Room

  • Use warm whites to create a welcoming, relaxed vibe.
  • Great paired with soft lighting and natural wood.
  • Try: White Dove (Benjamin Moore), Alabaster (Sherwin-Williams)

🛏 Bedroom

  • Soft whites help you unwind and rest.
  • Avoid anything too stark—it can feel sterile.
  • Try: Simply White (Benjamin Moore), Swiss Coffee (Behr)

🍽 Kitchen & Bathroom

  • Crisp, clean whites give a fresh and modern look.
  • Brighten up spaces with tile, stainless steel, or stone.
  • Try: Chantilly Lace (Benjamin Moore), Pure White (Sherwin-Williams)

🖼 Trim, Ceilings & Doors

  • Use a true white or something slightly brighter than your walls.
  • Semi-gloss works best for durability and shine.

🎯 Don’t forget—your furniture, flooring, and decor all impact how white appears. The best shade in a catalog might not work in your home unless everything else fits.

Top White Paints Designers and Homeowners Swear By

If you’re feeling overwhelmed, these tried-and-true whites are a great place to start:

Benjamin Moore

  • Chantilly Lace – Bright and clean with no strong undertone. Very popular for modern homes.
  • White Dove – A warm, soft white. Works in almost any room.
  • Simply White – Slightly warm, good for open spaces and trim.

Sherwin-Williams

  • Alabaster – A creamy, inviting white that never feels cold.
  • Pure White – A neutral white with just a touch of gray. Very versatile.
  • Snowbound – A cooler white, great for kitchens and modern bathrooms.

Farrow & Ball

  • All White – No undertones at all. Feels fresh and clean.
  • Strong White – A hint of gray adds depth without darkness.

These colors are consistent winners because they look great in a variety of spaces and lighting conditions.

Sheen Changes Everything: Picking the Right Finish

Once you’ve found your white, the next step is choosing the right finish. Sheen affects both how your paint looks and how easy it is to clean.

Flat or Matte

  • No shine at all
  • Hides flaws, but can be tough to clean
  • Best for ceilings or low-traffic rooms

Eggshell

  • Very slight shine
  • Durable and easy to wipe down
  • Perfect for living rooms, dining rooms, and hallways

Satin

  • Smooth with more sheen than eggshell
  • Great for kitchens, bathrooms, and trim
  • Easy to clean and holds up to moisture

Semi-Gloss or Gloss

  • High shine and very durable
  • Best for doors, baseboards, and cabinetry

💡 Pro tip: Use multiple finishes in the same room for contrast. A satin wall with semi-gloss trim adds depth and elegance!

Mistakes to Avoid When Choosing White Paint

White can be tricky. Avoid these common slip-ups:

  • Skipping samples. Paint looks different on your wall than it does on the swatch.
  • Mixing undertones. Warm and cool whites rarely play well together.
  • Choosing the wrong sheen. A flat finish in a busy hallway will show scuffs fast.
  • Ignoring your surroundings. Countertops, curtains, and floors affect how white looks.
  • Rushing the process. Take your time and test before you commit.

We’ve fixed plenty of “oops” jobs where the wrong white was used—and trust us, prevention is way easier than correction!

Sampling is a Must: How to Test White Paint the Right Way

Never skip this step. Sampling is the only way to know how a white will look in your space.

Here’s how to do it right:

  1. Pick your top 2–3 whites.
  2. Get sample pots from the paint store.
  3. Paint large swatches (about 12 inches square) on different walls.
  4. Check them at different times—morning, afternoon, and night.
  5. Use painter’s tape to label each swatch.

Still not sure? Let That 1 Painter Williamsburg handle it. Our experts will help you pick samples, test them properly, and choose a shade you’ll love for years.

Why White Paint is So Powerful

White paint can do it all.

It makes small rooms feel bigger. It reflects light and brightens your space. It creates a clean slate for any style—whether you love minimalism, farmhouse, coastal, or classic.

And white is timeless. Trends may come and go, but white? It’s always in.

  • It brings peace and clarity.
  • It blends beautifully with wood, metal, and stone.
  • It lets your artwork and furniture shine.
  • It’s both simple and bold.

When chosen carefully, the right shade of white makes a space feel just right. Like home.

Let That 1 Painter Williamsburg Help You Find the Perfect White

Choosing the right shade of white is more than just picking a color—it’s about setting the tone for your entire home. Whether you want a warm, cozy living room or a sleek, modern kitchen, your white paint needs to work with your lighting, finishes, and decor.

At That 1 Painter Williamsburg, we take the guesswork out of the process. From free color consultations to expert sampling and flawless finishes, we help homeowners like you find your perfect white.

We’re not painting contractors—we’re painting professionals. We care about every detail. Every brushstroke. Every room you live in.

🖌️ Ready to make your space feel brighter, cleaner, and more you?

Contact us at That 1 Painter Williamsburg today and let’s bring your vision to life.
Your perfect white is just one paint can away.

READY TO GET STARTED?

Contact us for a free onsite estimate within 24 hours.

BOOK NOW